22  Such a mechanism for change was perfectly suited to the nineteenth-century mindset, with its uneasy ambivalence between the popular myth of social mobility, and the more comfortable conventions of social and professional channeling.
     While phrenology's limitations were eventually revealed by modern science, in many ways it was far more right than wrong.  Gall's seminal discoveries, coupled with the "nodal" theory of brain function, were confirmed by twentieth century psychologists.   Sociology can trace its beginnings to the fathers of the phrenological movement.  Even the social reforms of the nineteenth century owe a debt to the phrenological doctrines of development potential, educability, and the like.  In a more ephemeral way, however, phrenology contributed to the advancement of American society by empowering the population, giving them the modern, scientific foundation they required to control and shape the future.  It is for that reason that it should be remembered as more than a fad--it was a potent instrument of modernity.
Related Links:
Maintained by John van Wyhe, Ph.D.--Very Comprehensive
Phrenology and the Fine Arts
Further exploration of Colbert's work--Excellent charts and graphics, as well as interactive areas.
Reading Heads and Ruling Passions
Educational, maintained by the Macleay Museum at the University of Sydney
End Notes:
1. Jack Larkin, The Reshaping of Everyday Life 1790-1840. New York: HarperPerennial, 1988. p. 6.
2. Donald M. Scott, "The Popular Lecture and the Creation of a Public in Mid-Nineteenth-Century America," The Journal of American History 66, no. 4. (March 1980): 801.
3. Steven Mintz. Moralists and Modernizers. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1995. p. 80.
4. Scott, 802.
5. "Reviews and Literary Notices," Atlantic Monthly, VI (July 1860), 120. As quoted in Scott, 808.
6. Charles Colbert. A Measure of Perfection: Phrenology and the Fine Arts in America. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1997. 2
7. Colbert, 4.
8. Colbert, 7.
9. Boston Medial and Surgical Journal, VII. (Oct. 17, 1832) 162. As quoted by Robert E. Rigel, American Historical Review 39, No. 1 (Oct. 1933), 74.
10. H.T. Judson, "Alphabet of Phrenology," The New-England Magazine 5, no. 3(September 1833): 251.
11. "The Way They Do Things in Athens," Athenian, 7 July 1831.
12. Riegel, 76.
13. Riegel, 77.
14. Riegel, 78.
15. "Mesmerism," Southern Banner, 3 March 1843.
16. "Phrenology," Southern Banner, 2 July 1836.
17. "Lecture on Phreno-Mnenotechy," Southern Banner, 9 March 1847.
18. Colbert, 77.
19. Colbert, 73.
20. Allan S. Horlick, "Phrenology and the Social Education of Young Men," History of Education Quarterly 11, no. 1 (Spring, 1971): 32.
21. Letter to the American Phrenological Journal, requoted in Horlick, 27.
22. Horlick, 29.